Pennsylvania Dental Insurance

Average Premiums & Other Costs

Below is a recent analysis of Pennsylvania dental plans to help you evaluate your dental plan options. To obtain a quote of dental plan premiums for your specific area and age (and relatives if seeking family coverage), visit our dental insurance quote page.

An analysis of 39 dental plans offered in the state of Pennsylvania for 2023 found dental coverage in a variety of forms:

• 76 percent were Preferred Provider Organizations (PPO dental insurance)
• 5 percent were Health Maintenance Organizations (HMO dental insurance)
• 16 percent were Indemnity dental coverage
• A dental discount program (an alternative to traditional insurance) accounted for 3 percent of the options

Some dental plans from Nationwide and Humana also combined vision benefits with standard dental care.

Premiums and deductibles were compared given a standardized applicant profile. The least expensive offering within the study had a monthly premium of $7.89 a month. This plan was the Select Plan Basic, a HMO from Dominion National. The most expensive was the Humana Extend 5000 Dental PPO+Vision dental plan that included additional vision coverage. This plan had a monthly premium of 94.99. Monthly premiums across all 39 Pennsylvania plans examined averaged $39.79 a month.

Deductibles and Out-of-Pocket Costs

Deductibles were inconsistent among plans. 15.4 percent of plans had no deductible. Some plans had a deductible that was waived for certain preventive services. The average deductible was $56.41 per enrollee. For plans charging a deductible, slightly more than half of plans charged a single individual $50 annually. There was a single person deductible as high as $150 but this deductible was only charged once and was not paid again for as long as a person remained continuously enrolled within the dental plan.

Family deductibles were more expensive than individual deductibles, as would be expected. Some plans charged a $50 annual deductible for each family member enrolled. Other plans capped the maximum annual deductible for a family. In some cases, the family deductible was a flat charge (e.g. $150) while in others it was a maximum number of deductibles (e.g. $100 per person with a maximum of three deductibles per family). These capped family deductibles were as low as $75 and as high as $450 (the high deductible was only paid once for as long as the family stayed enrolled within the plan).

With respect to out-of-pocket costs for dental services, charges varied. With respect to budget-friendly options, we found that 64.1 percent of plans examined did not charge a copay for annual teeth cleaning in the first year of coverage. On the expensive end of the spectrum, there were several plans that did not cover high-cost root canals or crowns during the first year of enrollment in the dental plan. Additionally, most plans had a cap on what the dental plan would pay annually toward enrollee dental expenses. The lowest caps (known as a “maximum benefit”) in the first year of coverage were found in Guardian’s Advantage Starter and Advantage Core. Both plans had a $500 maximum benefit. The highest cap was $5,000, found in both the Humana Extend 5000 Dental PPO+Vision dental plan and the NCD Nationwide 5000 Plan PPO. Two HMO plans and one dental discount card had no cap:

• Dominion National Select Plan Basic
• Dominion National Select Plan Premium
• Careington 500

Among the 36 dental plans that capped payments, the average limit was $1,742 annually.

Pennsylvania Dental Insurance Companies

The 38 plans analyzed for this article represented nine separate insurers:

• Ameritas
• Careington
• Delta Dental
• Dominion National
• Guardian
• Humana
• Metlife
• Nationwide
• NCD
• Renaissance

Average Costs Vs A Personalized Rate Quote

With the information provided above, you can compare local rates to larger Pennsylvania cost trends. The following link will provide dental insurance quotes for plans available in your zip code, whether you’re up in Pittsburg, down in Philadelphia, or anywhere in-between. You can also review the plans below, which are DentalInsurance.com’s bestselling plans in Pennsylvania.

Dentistry in Pennsylvania

According to information published by Dentagraphics, Pennsylvania has 3,710 general dental practices and 3,556 specialty dental practices. The average income of a general dentist in the state during 2020 was $155,360 according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The United States Census Bureau estimates the state to have nearly 13 million residents in 2021, which produces a ratio of 3,494 Pennsylvanians per general dental practice. Not surprisingly, the government's Health Resources & Services Administration in 2018 determined that there are 58 Dental Health Professional Shortage Areas within the state.

Despite these pockets where dentists are less plentiful, the state has a robust dental plan market as the following section demonstrates.

Chart of PA Dental Plan Details for this Study

The following chart provides details on the coverage trend in our Pennsylvania dental plan study. Please use this information when evaluating the coverage provided in a dental plan you are considering.